The liner notes to this two-CD set do not explain how the meeting came about or why it took 16 years to release its results. Perhaps only critics fret over such uncertainties. What matters is that on Feb. 8, 2003, Mark Turner (an adventurous New York tenor saxophonist, not yet as prominent as he would become) and Gary Foster (almost 30 years older, a fixture on the Los Angeles studio scene, already a cult figure among alto saxophonists) performed a concert in an auditorium in Claremont, Calif. It was the only time they ever played together.
They were musicians with dissimilar styles from different generations, but they met on common ground: the arcane melodic/harmonic environment associated with Lennie Tristano, Warne Marsh, and Lee Konitz, often imprecisely categorized as “cool.” The concert turns them loose for an hour and a half on rich repertoire like Tristano’s “Lennie’s Pennies,” Konitz’s “Subconscious-Lee,” and Marsh’s “Background Music.” The chordless quartet contains bassist Putter Smith and drummer Joe LaBarbera.
The event feels loose and casual. The format is unapologetically head-solos-head. Tracks and solos run long. Turner has time for a vast five-minute a cappella cadenza that finally crystallizes into “Come Rain or Come Shine.”
This album is one long seamless continuum of melodic theme-and-variation. Two exceptional improvisers derive a remarkable quantity of attractive spontaneous ideas from their source materials. The best track is the shortest. Foster opens “What’s New?” with a soft cry straight up from the soul, languidly, shamelessly caresses the melody, then floats slowly downriver on the gentle currents of the song. The audio quality of this live recording is just good enough to allow the listener to revel in Foster’s alto saxophone sound, one of the most seductive in jazz.
Are you a musician or jazz enthusiast? Sign up for our weekly newsletter, full of reviews, profiles and more!