Become a member and get exclusive access to articles, live sessions and more!
Start Your Free Trial

Carol Sloane: Live at Birdland (Club 44)

A review of the singer's first new album in a dozen years

JazzTimes may earn a small commission if you buy something using one of the retail links in our articles. JazzTimes does not accept money for any editorial recommendations. Read more about our policy here. Thanks for supporting JazzTimes.
Carol Sloane: Live at Birdland (Club 44)
The cover of Live at Birdland by Carol Sloane

The short list of active jazz vocalists forged in the crucible of the 1950s scene, when earning esteem required honing an individual sound, includes Carol Sloane—as this album makes gloriously evident. Too prolific a recording artist to qualify as overlooked and too widely admired to be a cult figure, Sloane still seems grievously undervalued given the pleasure of her company.

Her first new album in a dozen years is a milestone-marking gift celebrating the 60th anniversary of her first album, 1962’s Live at 30th Street (originally released on Columbia and yet to be reissued in North America). Unlike her debut—a studio session with invited guests—Live at Birdland (recorded in 2019) captures then-82-year-old Sloane kibitzing with the audience and offering incisive commentary on her repertoire.

There’s an elegance to the set that bears close study, starting with the jaunty, boastful opener “Havin’ Myself a Time.” Her voice has certainly lost some luster from her prime, but she retains her cool warmth, agile phrasing, and nonpareil sense of time. Buoyed by superlative support from pianist Mike Renzi and bassist Jay Leonhart, and Scott Hamilton’s convivial tenor sax chatter, Sloane wrings every last drop of emotion from each song. She tosses in a few brisk swingers, like “You’re Driving Me Crazy,” but this autumnal program centers on loss and fear of loss, including devastating renditions of “I Don’t Want to Walk Without You” and “If I Should Lose You.” Her smartly paired medley of “Glad to Be Unhappy” and “I Got a Right to Sing the Blues” amplifies and somehow diffuses the self-pity running through both standards.

The stroke she suffered in 2020 means that Live at Birdland is likely her valedictory statement. For jazz lovers everywhere, thank you, Ms. Sloane.

Learn more about Live at Birdland at Amazon and Barnes & Noble!

Carol Sloane: Dearest Duke

Andrew Gilbert

Andrew Gilbert is a Berkeley-based freelancer who has written about arts and culture since 1989 for numerous publications, including the San Francisco Chronicle, San Jose Mercury News, Boston Globe, Los Angeles Times, East Bay Express, Berkeleyside, and KQED’s California Report. Born and raised in Los Angeles, he experienced a series of mind-blowing epiphanies listening to jazz masters at Kuumbwa Jazz Center in the late 1980s, performances he remembers more vividly than the gigs he saw last month.