If jazz is an art form based on surprise and discovery, spontaneity and intuition, then there’s something remarkably un-jazz-like about Israeli bassist Avishai Cohen’s 13th album.
These nine duets, recorded with young fellow-countryman, pianist Nitai Hershkovitz, display a considered poise and calculated elegance more akin to classical piano music. In fact, in places, these originals – as well as the reinterpretations of standards by Thelonius Monk, John Coltrane and Cole Porter – sound more like one of French pianist Jacques Loussier’s jazz makeovers of the work of Bach or Debussy.
It’s partly to do with the arrangements. The absence of a drummer imbues the music with a hushed, studious intimacy while simultaneously robbing it of any urgency, any fire, or any sense of, yes, let’s call it swing.
And it’s partly a result of the way Cohen plays his instrument: with an unerring melodic accuracy that’s always deeply, firmly, resolutely "in." If this album were a colouring book, there would be not even the slightest speck of ink straying over the lines.
And sometimes, frankly, you want a bit of mess. Take, for instance, the duo’s reworking of Monk’s gloriously eccentric, beautifully shambling, beatifically hip classic Criss Cross. There’s not even of the slightest hint of Monk’s Zen-like hesitations and in-the-moment joie de vivre. Instead, all of Cohen’s notes – both in the strident arco head and the briskly plucked walking choruses – are bold, confident, sharply defined brushstrokes, while Hershkovitz’s solo displays a silky sophistication that seems to miss the off-beat humour of Monk’s composition. It’s all just a little too neat.
None of which is to deny that there’s some top-flight musicianship at work here. Hershkovitz is a genuine prodigy – still only in his mid-20s but already playing with relaxed authority. And Cohen commands a fairly astonishing post-John Patitucci digital dexterity that explains why he’s one of the hottest tickets on the corporate global jazz stage today. But some will prefer the back-street stumblers over this sort of precision any day.
More Articles in Community Articles
Red Cat Publicity Recap of 2013 CD Releases
Jason Paul Harman Byrne
LARRY RENI THOMAS TOP TEN JAZZ 2013
Larry Reni Thomas
SFJAZZ Collective at the Ferguson Center in Newport News, Va.
Best of the Best for 2013
London-Based Label RareNoiseRecords Presents a Night of Progressive Music at Shapeshifter Lab, Dec. 13 at 8PM
Preparing For Fame
Kathryn Ballard Shut