April 1997

Kenny Wheeler and Paul Bley
[Touche]
Justin Time Records
Han Bennink and Dave Douglas
Serpentine
Songlines

When two musicians perform together-without a net, as it were-we hear their individual skills, but we hear them in the context of their understanding of one another. Particularly in free improvisation, in the absence of the listener's traditional framework, the ear tends to hear the whole, not just the doughnut or the eclair. These two recordings are a gratifying lesson in the range of music embraced by free jazz, instructive both in their similarities and their differences.

It is tempting to try to generalize about these two duos in order to distinguish between them. Considering Douglas' trumpet, paired with the neo-percussion (and harmonica and "french" violin [sic] and other stuff [sic rursus]!) of Han Bennink, one might say that the relationship is about time and texture-and perhaps tongue-in-cheek. But this leaves out too much-the elegant balance the two have crafted into each piece, whether freely improvised or based on a chestnut like "Too Close for Comfort" or "Cherokee." Looking at Kenny Wheeler's approach to collaborating with pianist Paul Bley, one might suggest timbre and space as being the primary concerns of the players-but what then of the elegance of line that marks the whole CD, or the way each refracts the other's ideas in the moment? Is Douglas more "tonal" in his approach, as witness the walking sixths motif that drives his composition "Delft?" Well, not really, hearing the plangent, tonal lyricism of Wheeler's "Doing Time." Two CDs, very different, much in common: Wrap your ears around both.

Originally published in April 1997
BUY THIS ALBUM from Amazon.com
STREAM THIS CD from Rhapsody.com

Add a Comment

You need to log in to comment on this article. No account? No problem!