Mats_hidros_span3 Thing_garage_span3
March 2005

Mats Gustafsson and Sonic Youth
Hidros 3
Smalltown Supersound
The Thing
Garage
Smalltown Supersound

It would be harsh of me to suggest that a cannonball to the gut would be more pleasurable than listening to the glutinous mess that is Hidros 3 for even one second longer than required to write this review, but harsh I will be. I admire Sonic Youth for expanding the possibilities of song-based rock 'n' roll, but since I don't really like song-based rock 'n' roll, my praise might ring a bit hollow. As improvisers, they leave me cold. Contrabass saxophonist/conceptualist Mats Gustafsson enlisted the help of five guitarists-including SY members Lee Ranaldo and Thurston Moore-a pair of vocalists (one of them SY's Kim Gordon), and a person playing an "audiobox." The group improvised at length while Jim O'Rourke did a live mix. Waves of distorted guitars and the occasional ranting vocal dominate. This is noisy, anti-virtuosic energy/ambient music. The "best" moment comes about 25 minutes in, when Gustafsson goes nuts on contrabass sax. The sounds he gets out of the thing-while wildly unattractive-certainly defy description. I appreciate the inspiration behind the attempt to unleash one's raging id upon the world, but this kind of thing is effective only when it puts forth a unique vision. This doesn't. Speaking of which.…

The Thing is Gustafsson on tenor and baritone saxes, Ingebrigt Haker Flaten on bass and Paal Nilssen-Love on drums, and on Garage they play mostly a repertoire of punk-ish tunes by rock bands like the White Stripes ("Aluminum") and the Yeah Yeah Yeahs ("Art Star"). Over the very loud rhythm section Gustafsson blows tired Ayler-isms-lots of slap-tonguin', reed bitin' and fundamental over-blowin'. I like the way he splits his tone into its component parts on Norman Howard's "Haunted," but for the most part, Gustafsson is a 15th generation Xerox copy of Albert Ayler playing tunes by 15th generation Xerox copies of the Ramones. What horrors hath the Bad Plus wrought?

Originally published in March 2005
BUY THIS ALBUM from Amazon.com
STREAM THIS CD from Rhapsody.com

Add a Comment

You need to log in to comment on this article. No account? No problem!